Jersey Mike's Subs

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.3

( 8 reviews )

Delis, Sandwiches

Closed 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours

251 Main St, Matawan, NJ 07747, United States

+1 7329-704-422

Jersey Mike's Subs is a popular sandwich shop located at 251 Main St, Matawan, NJ. Offering a wide range of freshly made, delicious sandwiches, this location has garnered praise for its exceptional service and high-quality food. Customers have repeatedly expressed their satisfaction with the friendly and helpful staff, as well as the consistent freshness of the sandwiches. The manager, Emily, has received praise for her dedication to ensuring that customers receive the best service and value for their money, especially when placing large orders for events or luncheons. The store has become a go-to spot for many locals, with its warm and inviting atmosphere, making it a pleasant place to enjoy a quick lunch break. With its convenient location and excellent reputation, Jersey Mike's Subs in Matawan has become a favorite choice for sandwich lovers in the area.

Amenities and More

Kerbside pickup
Takeaway
Accepts reservations
Credit cards
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Kids' menu
High chairs
Wheelchair-accessible lift
Dinner
Tourists
Dogs allowed outside
University students

Reviews

4.3/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

David kramer

March 22, 2024

Jersey Mikes Subs is definitely a good place to eat. Are they the best subs in the world - probably not, but they are very good. I don't think there is anything unique, except that they only do sandwiches and make good subs. Place is new and clean and friendly.

Owen reaves

March 22, 2024

I hope all Jersey Mikes aren’t the same like the one in Matawan , 2 slices of bacon on each quarter of the Giant BLT! Quite disappointing/

Kit slonk

March 22, 2024

Guys in this sandwich shop are great very polite make the sandwiches 🥪 really well 👊💪

Randall schneider

March 22, 2024

Staff does not listen! I literally just called and said can I get a large Philly cheesesteak with American cheese, onions, and Mayo no peppers. I also ordered a small chicken Philly with Mayo onions and ketchup only. The girl literally rung my chicken Philly up as a bacon chicken cheesesteak! We don’t eat any pork at all! I called back and she had the audacity to tell me I ordered a bacon cheesesteak and passed the manager the phone! Like girl if you’re new just say that! Mind you I repeated my order to her twice! And she repeated “got you” over and over ! But literally messed up the entire order! Also my large cheesesteak was not good at all! My cheese wasn’t melted they didn’t put my onions or anything on it ! $30 wasted on two subs! Ridiculous! Smh very much upsetting & they could careless that this was our dinner… 01/22/2022 night shift! Please do better!!

Sarah sleepysaur

March 22, 2024

My experience with JM in Matawan has been nothing but positive. I had to place a big order for one of the local high school clubs and had to stay within a tight budget. Emily the manager, worked with me to figure out what would be the best deal and helped with keeping me within the budget. It was great seeing a manager work hard to help out and explain the many options I had. Kids loved the subs and break from the usual pizza lunch for their events. Definitely going back for more catering.

Screamnshout thompson

March 22, 2024

Ridiculously stingy with toppings. Literally half the amount of roast beef in my beef and provolone compared to what I get in other franchises. Avoid.

Deb mark

March 22, 2024

I have had the best experience with JM in Matawan. They have been amazing working with us for a luncheons we provide for our HS students. Everything is always fresh and the kids love the sandwiches. Everything is always ready for pickup on time and the staff is always so friendly and helpful. I cannot say enough great things about this location!!!

Brandy m

March 22, 2024

I come to this Jersey Mikes multiple times a week, each and every time receive the best service and such a warm welcome. The manager is the sweetest woman you could ever meet & always goes above and beyond to make sure everyone is happy including her staff and customers. Couldn’t ask for a better way to spend my lunch break! Thank you so much Jersey Mike’s team, you guys make it special and far beyond pleasant!!! 10 stars across the board